T&T Clark Search Engine

  • Site Search

The T&T Clark Editors

  • Anna Turton
    Senior Commissioning Editor, Theology (UK)
  • Dominic Mattos
    Editorial Director, Biblical Studies (UK)

« Requiescat In Pace, Henry Chadwick | Main | In the news: Elizabeth Johnson [NCR] »

June 25, 2008

Comments

Ben George

Wouldn't it be a good idea to keep the old page numbers in the brackets (maybe in small print) so as to maintain referential continuity?

Ben Myers

Looks great! And I agree with the comment above: I reckon you should keep the old page numbers in brackets; otherwise anyone reading pre-2008 Barth scholarship would find it hard to locate references.

David W. Congdon

Excellent! The page layout is sharp and clear. As one who works at the Barth Center, I am very happy to see the translations included.

And I also concur with the comments above. It would be very unwise to remove the old page numbers. The amount of English scholarship relying on the older edition is just huge!

Tom

Many thanks for all your comments. This is very helpful. To make this more user friendly: Do you think the page numbers are enough - or should we also include the volume of the old edition?

WTM

Tom, I agree that the old edition page numbers need to stay. Reference to the part-volume of the old edition can be made on the title page or on one of the frontage pages; it need not be repeated throughout.

Ben Myers

Just one additional thought: I know it's much too late for this, but it seems a shame that the footnotes all had to be prefixed with "EN". Since Barth himself doesn't use footnotes, the translation notes could have just been numbers. (But then of course you would have had to change the Bromiley edition's system of using superscription for biblical references — too much editorial fiddling, I guess!)

Clay Jackson

I also agree that you should definitely keep the page numbers in brackets in the final version. It would be next to impossible to actually USE this new edition otherwise, because you wouldn't be able to look up citations quoted in secondary literature.

The brackets are unobtrusive as they stand now, and it makes it a very helpful contribution.

Clay Jackson

Sorry to pile on here, but I hit post too early--I was going to add another point in favor of keeping the brackets.

To my mind, one of the biggest assets of this new edition is that it is more student and classroom friendly. A professor is much more likely to assign one of these smaller volumes for a class than one of the traditional volumes, both because of size and price. Without the traditional numbers in brackets , however, it would be nearly impossible for a student to perform research (say, for a term paper) using her book because her pagination would be different than the one used by in nearly all the secondary literature for over seven decades! This means that one of this edition's greatest asset--it's potential to used in classrooms--is greatly diminished.

In any event, I'm excited about this new edition. I think it will lead to a lot more students, pastors, and lay people reading Barth, because Barth will be much more accessible than before. Bravo!

Terry

I'm not sure how practical or user-friendly it would be to add yet more pagination details, but would it also be possible to include pagination from the German edition so those working with both the original language texts and the English translation can make connections more easily?

James

Loving it -- look forward to Christmas. Typeset positively crystalline.

N.b. if you've time to change it there's a typo in the second line of the Greek on sample page 013 -- should be a space between "tis" and "yap".

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)